How to give feedback to employees: describe one specific piece of work, say what it caused, ask for their view and agree what happens next. Do it soon, and in private if it is critical. Name the work, not the person. "The report reached the client two days late" is feedback; "you are careless" is a verdict. Twenty examples follow.
Key takeaways
- Feedback is about one piece of work, with a date. If you cannot point to the work, wait until you can.
- Say what happened, what it caused, and then stop and listen. The employee's view is part of the feedback.
- Praise is as specific as criticism. "Good job" is pleasant and forgettable.
- Give it soon. Waiting for the appraisal makes it a surprise and gives the person no chance to fix anything.
- Write down what you agreed and look at it next time.
How to give feedback to employees in five steps
- Prepare in two minutes. Have the example in front of you: the date, the document, the call. Decide the one thing you want to change or keep. If you are angry, wait a day.
- Choose the place. Praise can be public if the person likes it. Criticism is private, face to face, and not in front of a customer or the team. For hard conversations, do not use a chat message, which cannot carry tone.
- Say what you saw and what it caused. Name the situation, the behaviour and the impact. This is the structure the Center for Creative Leadership calls Situation-Behaviour-Impact (CCL), and how to build rapport with a new team explains it in detail. Here we concentrate on the sentences.
- Ask, then listen. "What was happening from your side?" Often the cause is a missing tool, an unclear priority or a clash of two instructions, and it is yours to fix. Teams where people defer to seniors may stay silent out of respect, so ask a second time: "what would you add?"
- Agree the next step and follow it up. One action, one owner, one date. Put it in your next one-on-one and look at it.
How often? Gallup's article on feedback reports that employees are 3.6 times more likely to strongly agree that they are motivated to do outstanding work when their manager gives them daily rather than annual feedback (Gallup). That does not mean a daily speech. It means small, specific comments as the work happens, so the appraisal has no surprises in it.
What are good examples of constructive feedback?
Each row names the situation, gives the words, and shows what to avoid. Change the details to fit the case.
| # | Situation | What to say | What to avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Submits reports late | "The weekly sales report arrived on Tuesday, two days after the deadline, so I could not send the figures to the director before his Wednesday meeting. What is getting in the way, and what would help?" | "You are always late." |
| 2 | Misses a target | "Collections came in at 84% against the 90% target. Walk me through the three accounts that held it back." | "You are not trying hard enough." |
| 3 | Rude tone with a customer | "On the call at 2 pm, you interrupted the customer twice. She ended the call upset and has asked for a manager. Let's listen to it together and look at what you could say instead." | "You are rude." |
| 4 | Arrives late | "You were in after 9 on four days this week, and the front desk was uncovered each time. Is there something making the morning hard, such as transport, that we should talk about?" | "You have no respect for time." |
| 5 | Mistakes in invoices | "Three of last week's invoices had the wrong VAT line. Finance had to reissue them, and one client received two versions. What check could you add before you send?" | "You are careless." |
| 6 | Poor handover | "When you went on leave, the Abuja account had no notes. Folake spent a day finding out what had been promised. Next time, I'd like the status and open promises written down before you go." | "You left a mess." |
| 7 | Silent in meetings | "In Monday's meeting you had the most knowledge of the supplier issue, and we only heard it afterwards from Emeka. I'd like your view in the room. What would make that easier?" | "You never speak up." |
| 8 | Takes on too much and drops things | "You have said yes to five requests this week and two are now late. Let's look at your list and decide what you hand back." | "You can't say no." |
| 9 | Ignores the process | "The client discount was agreed on the phone but not logged, so the invoice went out at the full price. Please log every change when it is agreed." | "You never follow the rules." |
| 10 | Defensive when corrected | "When I raised the error just now, I felt you were explaining why it wasn't yours. I want to find the cause, not the culprit. Can we start with what happened?" | "You can't take criticism." |
| 11 | Messy records | "Half of this month's customer entries have no phone number, so the follow-up team could not reach 12 people. What's the quickest way to make the field required?" | "Your data is a mess." |
| 12 | Talks over colleagues | "In yesterday's review you spoke over Hauwa three times, and she stopped contributing. Let her finish, then respond." | "You are domineering." |
What are good examples of positive feedback?
Specific praise tells the person what to repeat. Add what it made possible.
| # | Situation | What to say |
|---|---|---|
| 13 | A hard customer was won back | "The way you called Mr Adeyemi back the same afternoon and offered a revised date kept a ₦3.2 million order. That is exactly what I want the team to do." |
| 14 | A report was clear | "Your report put the three decisions at the top. The director read it in two minutes and approved it the same day." |
| 15 | Someone helped a colleague | "You stayed late on Thursday to help Ngozi finish the stock count. Because of that, we could invoice on Friday." |
| 16 | A process improved | "Adding the checklist to the dispatch form cut the wrong-address returns from five to one this month. Thank you for building it." |
| 17 | A deadline was met under pressure | "You flagged on Monday that the deadline was at risk and told me what you needed. Because you said so early, we moved two tasks and made it." |
| 18 | A mistake was owned | "You told me about the pricing error before the client noticed. That let us fix it quietly, and I trust what you tell me because of it." |
| 19 | Quiet consistency | "You have closed every ticket within the target for six weeks. Nobody notices the thing that does not go wrong, so I'm noticing it." |
| 20 | Growth | "Three months ago you hesitated to present. Yesterday's client presentation was clear and calm. What did you do differently?" |
What if the conversation goes badly?
| What happens | What to do |
|---|---|
| They get angry or defensive | Stay calm, lower your voice, and say "I can see this is hard to hear. Let's take five minutes." Return to the example, not the emotion |
| They cry | Pause, offer water and a few minutes, and carry on gently. It is not a reason to drop the point |
| They say "nobody told me" | Check whether that is true. If it is, own it and set the standard clearly from today |
| They blame someone else | Ask what part is theirs and what part needs fixing elsewhere. Both can be true |
| They agree and nothing changes | Write the action, owner and date, and check it at the next meeting |
| They say "this is unfair" | Ask what is unfair. Show your evidence, and listen to theirs. If they have a point, say so |
If the same issue returns after clear feedback and support, a written plan with dates is the next step. See our performance improvement plan template.



