A staff appraisal form records how one person performed against agreed goals over a set period, and what happens next. A good one holds KPIs with a weight, target and actual, competency ratings on a 1 to 5 scale, achievements and gaps, development actions and both signatures. Copy the template below, then see it filled in.
Key takeaways
- Agree the KPIs and their weights at the start of the period. An appraisal that introduces the targets at the end is a surprise, not an appraisal.
- Rate the evidence, not the impression. Every rating needs a number, a date or a piece of work beside it.
- Keep results (KPIs) and behaviours (competencies) in separate parts, and say how much each counts for.
- The employee fills in a self assessment first, the manager second, and both sign.
- Hold the conversation about development separately from the conversation about pay, or the pay will drown out everything else.
What should a staff appraisal form include?
A form people trust has the same seven parts in any business. Leave one out and you will feel it at the meeting.
| Part | What it holds | Who fills it in |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Details | Name, role, department, manager, appraisal period, date of last appraisal | Manager |
| 2. KPIs and results | Each KPI with its weight, target and actual, and a score from 1 to 5 | Employee proposes, manager confirms |
| 3. Competencies | Four to six behaviours that matter for the role, each rated 1 to 5 with an example | Employee and manager, separately |
| 4. Achievements and gaps | The two or three things done best, and the two or three that fell short, with evidence | Employee first, then manager |
| 5. Overall rating | One rating, with the reason in a sentence | Manager |
| 6. Development and next period | Skills to build, support needed, the next period's KPIs | Both, agreed in the meeting |
| 7. Comments and sign-off | The employee's own comment, both signatures, date | Both |
Gallup's research on reviews explains why the structure matters. In its 2017 survey write-up, only 14% of employees strongly agreed that their reviews inspire them to improve, 29% that they are fair and 26% that they are accurate (Gallup, 2017). The same article reports that employees whose managers involve them in setting goals are four times more likely to be engaged. A form with agreed KPIs and evidence beside each rating is the simplest answer to "unfair" and "inaccurate".
The staff appraisal form template (copy this)
Paste this into a document or a spreadsheet, or download the form as a Word file. Replace the examples in brackets.
Download the staff appraisal form (Word)
Part 1. Details
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| Employee name | |
| Job title and department | |
| Manager | |
| Appraisal period | [for example 1 July to 31 December 2026] |
| Type | [probation / half-year / annual] |
Part 2. KPIs and results (counts for 70% of the overall score)
| KPI | Weight | Target | Actual | Score (1 to 5) | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [KPI 1] | [%] | ||||
| [KPI 2] | [%] | ||||
| [KPI 3] | [%] | ||||
| [KPI 4] | [%] | ||||
| Total | 100% | [sum] |
Rule for scoring a KPI from the result: below 75% of target scores 1; 75 to 89% scores 2; 90 to 99% scores 3; 100 to 109% scores 4; 110% or more scores 5. Write your own bands if the KPI works differently (a lower number can be better for something like error rate), but write them down before the period starts.
Part 3. Competencies (counts for 30%)
| Competency | Employee's rating | Manager's rating | One example that supports the rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Customer handling] | |||
| [Teamwork] | |||
| [Reliability] | |||
| [Communication] |
Part 4. Achievements and gaps
- Three things I did well this period, with the date or the result:
- Two things that fell short, and what got in the way:
- What I would do differently:
Part 5. Overall rating
Overall score: [KPI score x 0.7 + competency average x 0.3]. Rating: [Below Expectations / Developing / Meets Expectations / Exceeds Expectations / Exceptional]. Reason in one sentence:
Part 6. Development and next period
| Development need | Action | Support needed | By when |
|---|---|---|---|
Next period's KPIs, with weights and targets (agreed in the meeting):
Part 7. Comments and sign-off
Employee's comment (written by the employee, not the manager):
Signed, employee: ____ Date: __ Signed, manager: __ Date: ____
Signing means "we have discussed this", not "I agree with every word". Say so on the form, and let the employee write a comment if they disagree.
What does a filled-in staff appraisal form look like?
Here is an example for a made-up person, Chidinma Okafor, a sales officer at a building-materials distributor in Lagos, appraised for July to December 2026. It is an illustration; the numbers are invented.
Part 2, KPIs and results
| KPI | Weight | Target | Actual | % of target | Score | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue won | 40% | ₦24,000,000 | ₦22,200,000 | 92.5% | 3 | 1.2 |
| New customers won | 20% | 15 | 18 | 120% | 5 | 1.0 |
| Invoices paid within 30 days | 20% | 90% | 84% | 93% | 3 | 0.6 |
| Customer follow-up within 24 hours | 20% | 95% | 97% | 102% | 4 | 0.8 |
| Total | 100% | 3.6 |
Part 3, Competencies
| Competency | Chidinma | Manager | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Customer handling | 4 | 4 | Kept a contractor in Ibadan after a delayed delivery by calling him the same day with a revised date |
| Teamwork | 4 | 4 | Covered two weeks of a colleague's accounts during leave |
| Reliability | 3 | 3 | Two customer quotes went out a day late in October |
| Communication | 4 | 4 | Weekly update to the manager was complete every week |
| Average | 3.75 |
Part 5, Overall rating
Overall score = 3.6 x 0.7 + 3.75 x 0.3 = 2.52 + 1.125 = 3.645, about 3.6. Rating: Meets Expectations, near the top of the band. Reason: strong on new customers and follow-up, below target on revenue, and cash collection needs attention.
Part 6, Development
| Need | Action | Support | By when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collect on time | Agree payment dates at order, and flag any invoice 7 days late to the manager | Manager joins the first two calls | 31 January 2027 |
| Bigger orders | Shadow the senior officer on two large quotes | Manager arranges the visits | 28 February 2027 |
The suggested bands for the overall score (round as you like, but publish them before the period): below 1.5 is Below Expectations, 1.5 to 2.4 Developing, 2.5 to 3.7 Meets Expectations, 3.8 to 4.5 Exceeds Expectations, and 4.6 or more Exceptional. These bands are a starting point for a conversation. The manager's judgement, backed by the evidence in Part 4, sets the final rating.
How do you rate staff fairly on a 1 to 5 scale?
Define each point in words and say what evidence earns it. Without that, one manager's 4 is another's 3, which is how a team ends up thinking the process is unfair. This is the scale Rople's reviews use for competencies, which is a sensible default for any form.
| Score | Label | What it means | Evidence you should have |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Below Expectations | Regularly misses what the role requires | Several specific, dated examples, already discussed with the person |
| 2 | Developing | Meets some requirements, but not consistently | Mixed examples, with a plan to improve |
| 3 | Meets Expectations | Does the job well and reliably | Results at or near target, no surprises |
| 4 | Exceeds Expectations | Regularly does more than the role asks | Results above target, and examples of helping others |
| 5 | Exceptional | A standard others learn from | A clear, documented contribution beyond their own role |
Three habits keep the scale honest:
- Write the example before the number. If you cannot name one, the rating is a feeling.
- Rate the whole period. The last month is easy to remember and the first five are not. Keep a running record through the period (see the next section).
- Do not hide behind 3. If everyone is a 3, nobody learns anything. If everyone is a 4, the scale has stopped meaning anything.
Who fills in which part, and how often?
The order matters more than the paperwork. The employee goes first, so the manager reads the person's own account before writing theirs.
| Step | Who | What | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Manager | Agree KPIs, weights and targets for the period | Start of the period |
| 2 | Manager and employee | Short check-ins to catch problems early | Monthly or quarterly |
| 3 | Employee | Self assessment: Parts 2 to 4 | One week before the meeting |
| 4 | Manager | Own ratings and evidence | Before the meeting |
| 5 | Both | The appraisal meeting; agree Parts 5 to 7 | Within the same fortnight |
| 6 | Owner or HR | Review ratings across teams for consistency | After all meetings |
How often depends on the reason. Many Nigerian businesses appraise once a year, and some also at the end of probation, since the result decides whether the person is confirmed. Gallup recommends progress reviews at least every six months, and its survey found that 26% of employees are evaluated less than once a year (Gallup, 2017). A half-year rhythm with short quarterly check-ins is a workable middle for a small business. If the appraisal also feeds a salary review, hold the pay conversation in a separate meeting, a week or two later, as Sutton and Wigert suggest in Gallup's More Harm Than Good (2019).



